This page is a source for the links and materials needed to understand the planning procedure and to make rational objections, based on planning law as it stands, to the proposed wind farms. It is an ongoing project, and comments are welcome. For detailed information on individual wind farms, please go to their individual pages on this site: Dersalloch, Linfairn, Keirs Hill, Knockskae, Hadyard Hill Extension, Glenmount
Please note: there are now six wind farms which affect Straiton and the surrounding area. The Hadyard Hill Extension consists of 31 turbines at a maximum 126.5m high. There are already 52 turbines in this wind farm. Our composite map below is now out of date and there are some new Planning documents which we will upload in the near future.
- Info in brief on the five Straiton wind farm applications
- A composite map of all five wind farms
- Key documents which are used by the planning authorities in assessing wind farm applications
- Information on the Galloway and Southern Ayrshire Biosphere
- Information on the Galloway Forest Dark Sky Park
- Information and links about archaeological sites
Wind farms are now planned almost all around Straiton.
- Linfairn (about 4km from village, reduced from 25 to 17 turbines as of December 2014, located up the Girvan valley on Knockcronal, Big Benyaw and Genoch Inner Hill. Tip height of turbines 126.5m). Photomontages of the Linfairn wind farm: click here.
- Dersalloch (about 3km from village, over the back of the Monument Hill, 23 turbines: 16 turbines at 125m and 7 at 115m to tip). Consented on 23 July 2014.
- Keirs Hill (formerly Sclenteuch) (original plans for a wind farm on the old road from Straiton to Patna, 33 turbines at either 126.5m or 146.5m to blade tip: number reduced as of May 2013 to 17 turbines, height increased to 149m, centred on Keirs Hill – 1km from Patna, 3.7km from Straiton)
- Glenmount (up towards Loch Bradan – 26 turbines – reduced to 22 as of May 2013. Tip height up to 130m).
- Knockskae (Dalmorton) (up behind Linfairn farm – 11 turbines. Tip height 126m)
- Hadyard Hill Extension (joining on to existing wind farm near Barr, would almost join up with Knockskae).
COMPOSITE MAPS OF ALL FIVE WINDFARMS
This is somewhat out of date but will be replaced with an up-to-date version soon.
large scale JPG
large scale PDF
Click here for a Scottish Natural Heritage map of windfarm applications in Scotland as of August 2012 (this is a very large PDF, so will download slowly. It does not show Glenmount).
Photomontages of the Linfairn windfarm: visit Gallery page, or click here.
Key Documents List: these documents are in no particular order – apologies for their higgeldy-piggeldy presentation. All are relevant. If you would like to know where to start, our planning lead, Whirly Marshall, advises that the two most important documents are nos. IVa and IX on the list: Whirly has also provided PDF documents which summarise the key points in those documents.
I: Wind Farm Guidance
II: South Ayrshire Tourism Strategy 2012 – 2017
III: South Ayrshire Council Proposed Local Development Plan Strategic Environmental Assessment: Environmental Report
IV: South Ayrshire Proposed Local Development Plan
IVa: South Ayrshire Local Plan [the current one, not the proposed one!]
V: Proposed Galloway and Southern Ayrshire Biosphere Presentation
VI: The socio-economic potential of the Galloway and South Ayrshire Biosphere Reserve
VII: Ayrshire designed landscapes report Sep09 with maps
VIII: Ayrshire and Clyde valley landscape capacity study
IX: Approved Ayrshire Joint structure plan
X: Draft Modifications – Schedule (modifications to the above joint structure plan)
XI: Windfarms – distance from housing
XII: The economic impact of Wind farms on Scottish tourism
Aso known as Addendum to the Ayrshire Joint Structure Plan Technical Report TR03/2006 – Guidance on the Location of Windfarms within Ayrshire. This is a crucial document in assessing the suitability of windfarms in Ayrshire. We have not had time yet to prepare a summary of the key points. If anyone would like to comment, please do so. However, see the Linfairn page of this site, and comments on suitable land use, which are taken from this document.
This document outlines South Ayrshire’s strategy for tourism. It recognises the importance of walking, cycling and holidays and short breaks in the South Ayrshire hills, as well as the potential importance of the Dark Skies Park and the UNESCO Galloway Biosphere designation. For example (p. 11): Ayrshire and Arran has a varied and accessible natural environment. The countryside, coastline and seas offer a rich variety of landscapes, wildlife, habitats and geology for the visitor to enjoy and experience. There are emerging distinctive offerings and opportunities, such as establishing part of the Galloway Forest Park as the UK’s first Dark Sky Park and probably Scotland’s first UNESCO Biosphere designation [this is now definite – ed.]. However, the level of activity tourism is currently low and generally underdeveloped on mainland Ayrshire, with great potential to develop infrastructure, facilities and build this offering in areas such as walking, cycling, horse-riding and watersports. […]
Potential areas of action:
• Product development for walking and cycling, to package products more effectively for particular customer profiles.
• Infrastructure enhancements, such as joining up paths and cycleways, working with communities and businesses to provide improved facilities.
• Promote the development of related hospitality facilities through VisitScotland’s various ‘Welcome’ schemes.
• Encourage and facilitate collaboration among providers to overcome fragmentation and offer stronger, packaged experiences, tailored to distinctive market segments.
• Explore ways to attract more adventure and activity operators into the area.”
We have not yet had time to summarise this: if anyone would care to comment please do so.
OK, now listen carefully. There is a Local Development Plan and there is a Proposed Local Development plan. Document IV is the Proposed one.
“The [Proposed] Local Development Plan (LDP) is the new strategic land use document that, when complete, will replace the South Ayrshire Local Plan [q.v. – Document IVa on this page] and the Ayrshire Joint Structure Plan [q.v. Document IX on this page] as part of the wider modernisation of planning. It will set out strategic spatial priorities and policies for South Ayrshire and will secure land zoning for specified uses (e.g. land for housing/industry etc.) to provide increased certainty for development.
The preparation of the LDP will take place over the next 5 years and it is intended that it will be adopted in 2013.” (South Ayrshire website)
In other words, as if things weren’t complicated enough, we have to take account of all the documents, current and proposed.
Crucial sections of the Proposed Local Developmen Plan, as they refer to the windfarms around Straiton, are as follows:
(p. 5) Carrick investment area
Within the Carrick investment area we will encourage development if: […]
• it promotes the Galloway and Southern Ayrshire Biosphere and Galloway Forest Dark Sky Park; and
• wind farm developments are directed to preferred wind farm search areas.”
None of the wind farm developments around Straiton are in preferred wind farm search areas. See below for a map from the Ayrshire Joint Planning Steering Group showing the preferred search area for wind farm development in South Ayrshire:
The following is also from the South Ayrshire Proposed Local Development Plan.
South Ayrshire has above-average wind speeds and is an attractive area for generating wind energy and, in particular, as a location for wind farms. The Scottish Government has set a target for 100% of Scotland’s electricity to be generated from renewable sources by 2020, and onshore wind power is one of the main sources of renewable energy. Given the Government’s target, we have a responsibility to fi nd wind farm locations that would contribute to the overall national supply, while taking any effects on the environment into account. Local benefits arising from wind farms can be important to the economic future of rural communities.
LDP policy: wind energy We will support proposals if:
a. the landscape is capable of accommodating the development;
b. they respect the main features and character of the landscape and keep their effect on the andscape and the wider area to a minimum (through a careful choice of site and high-quality design and materials);
c. they do not have a significant detrimental effect on the amenity of nearby residents;
d. the cumulative impact is acceptable; and
e. they do not affect aviation, defence interest and broadcasting installations.
We will use these conditions and supplementary guidance on wind farms when considering proposals for wind farms and turbines. Proposals will be considered in relation to the criteria above and supplementary guidance on wind farm developments, which will identify preferred areas of search for wind farms. We will use the Landscape Capacity Study to help us decide the effect of proposals on the landscape.”
KEY DOCUMENT IVa: South Ayrshire Local Plan [the current one] (click to download)
This document is still in force, and it is important to know what it says. We have prepared some edited highlights: The following notes identify the key Policies of the Local Plan which are deemed to be relevant and some or all should be referred to in letters of objection. Further advice as to the drafting of these letters will be provided as the planning applications are publicised. Download the PDF file of our notes here: Key Local Planning Points. When you have mastered this you have to look at Document IV and Document IX as well!
Not so much a key document as an interesting one. This presentation is downloaded from the Galloway and Southern Ayrshire Biosphere website. I think the opening photograph is of Loch Doon, with the Big Hill of Glenmount (site of a proposed windfarm). Am I right? Can anyone comment to confirm or deny?
A report presented to the interested Local Councils including South Ayrshire. We have not had time to read or summarise as yet. Please comment if you can.
Vital document used for assessing land use and suitability for wind farms. Much complex information. One point of interest: the Stinchar valley is listed in this document as of National significance and high value. The proposed Linfairn site would be clearly visible from the tracks which border the upper Stinchar valley. Perhaps also from the lower valley towards Barr. Any comments?
We have summarised some key points which are relevant to windfarms, and which should be referred to in objectors’ letters. Advice on drafting letters will be given when a Planning Application is anticipated. Download the edited highlights of the Joint Structure Plan as a PDF file here: Key Joint Structure Points.
Modifications to the Ayrshire joint structure plan. Comments welcome.
People are often concerned that wind farms might be too close to houses. There are no statutory limits in the UK. This document prepared for MPs at Westminster explains the planning guidance in different parts of the UK, with the different likely effects on the distance from housing. It should be noted that in Scotland there is a presumption (not binding but recommended) that windfarms should not be developed within 2Km of settlements (including villages). It should also very important to note that not only Straiton itself but the clusters of houses up the Girvan valley as far as Tairlaw are considered by Ayrshire planning as part of a settlement, and so entitled to the protection of a 2Km buffer. This is clearly shown on the interactive mapping service for windfarm development offered by the Ayrshire Joint Planning Steering Group: it shows that only six turbines (nos. 1-4, 10, 11) of the proposed Linfairn development should be permitted (i.e. lie outside the recommended 2Km buffer zone. Similar restrictions will apply to Sclenteuch/Keirs Hill and Glenmount, and I will post screenshots of those maps in due course. See map on the Linfairn page of this website.
KEY DOCUMENT XII: The economic impact of wind farms on Scottish tourism (click to download)
This report was commissioned by the Scottish Government from the tourism unit at Glasgow Caledonian University. It is a long, thorough and complex report. The Scottish Government has briefed the press that the report shows that Wind farms have no effect on Scottish tourism. This seems to me to be a mis-representation. Careful reading of the document shows that the situation is complex. But the authors point out that the developments that they consider had already been screened by existing planning laws so that a negative effect on tourism was prevented. In other words, permission had not been granted for wind farms in sensitive tourist areas, and those that were NOT in sensitive tourist areas did not have a detrimental effect on tourism. This may seem self-evident, but it is a very important point, emphasised several times within the document: and it essentially negates any broad claim that there is no effect on tourism.
“There is often strong hostility to developments at the planning stage on the
grounds of the scenic impact and the knock on effect on tourism. However
the most sensitive of these do not appear to have been given approval so
that where negative impacts on tourism might have been a real outcome
there is, in practice, no evidence of a negative effect.”
Scottish government survey on impact of windfarms on tourism, p 67
It also states (p. 17)
“The research suggests that there is a need to make clearer to the general
public that in some “scenic/wilderness” areas they will not see large
commercial wind farms and that some other areas are positively marketed as
green centres of renewable energy. In this context it should be noted that this
research suggests that a few very large farms are better than a large number
of small farms. A number of medium size farms dispersed in a relatively small
area so that they become contiguous, is also not desirable. The current policy
on cumulative effects should thus be maintained.”
I hope to be doing further work on this key document. Please let me have your views if you have time to read it all!
The Galloway and Southern Ayrshire Biosphere has now been officially recognised by UNESCO. You will find details of it on the biosphere website and on UNESCO’s website. Below is a sketch map of the Biosphere from the Biosphere website. It shows that the upper Girvan valley down to just below Tairlaw (where it changes course) lies inside the “buffer” zone of the biosphere, which is conceived as “protecting the biospheres”. This buffer zone would have implications for two of the windfarms planned near Straiton: it would encompass the Glenmount windfarm site and would be touching the southern edge of the Linfairn windfarm site, at Genoch Inner Hill, which rises above Tairlaw.
The Galloway Forest Dark Sky park is recognised nationally and locally as a tourist asset (for example by South Ayrshire’s tourism strategy document: see above). The map below shows the extent of both the Dark Sky Park and its (vital) buffer zone. The boundary of the buffer zone is contiguous with the southern edge of the Linfairn windfarm, and the Glenmount windfarm. Turbines at both windfarms would be likely to require lighting at night to avoid danger to aircraft. Both these proposed windfarms lie closer to the Dark Sky park than the Dersalloch windfarm, which, we understand is giving the Scottish government cause for concern because of its impact on the Dark Sky Park.
A useful site for finding out about the many archaeological sites around Straiton and district is the West of Scotland Archaeological Service, which has a searchable database. A search for “Straiton” lists 256 separate sites. You could also try the database at Scotland’s Places which is sponsored by a number of major Scottish institutions. See the jpg below for an image of archaeological sites in the area, as mapped by the Ayrshire Joint Planning Steering Group. Archaeological sites are the faint orangey-pink blobs. There is a large number in the area of the proposed Linfairn windfarm: click here to see the detailed archaeological site information on the Linfairn page.